Era 3

Treacy found that he would rather split the workload of producing such a channel and so brought back channel creator Jon Gransden.

This would be the first controversial event in FiveWhoFans, Treacy and Gransden decided to "reset the counter" on the videos, and so they deleted both previous eras videos.

This caused an outcry from subscribers and past members who were upset to lose the history of the channel. It even lead to one subscriber email all other subscribers and pushing them to un-subscribe to "teach the new team a lesson".

Regardless of this "hiccup", Treacy and Gransden re-launched the channel.

Matthew Perks left in this era, Jamie Carroll only did two videos - His introduction and his first review of 'Rose'. Matthew Perks was the only member left after Treacy and Gransden had finished their run. Matthew was then selected for the next era.